Halloween Love
Horror on Amazon

Listen While You Read?

Want to write for HL? Read here first. // Creator? Want to promote your project? Read here first.

Five Things I Don’t Hate About the Nightmare on Elm Street Remake

Nightmare on Elm Street

Let me be clear about something right off the bat; I hate the Nightmare on Elm Street remake.

No, I don’t hate it simply because I hate remakes or because I’m so loyal to the original films. True, I do have a deep love for the Elm Street movies, but I’m not one of these fans who blindly hates all remakes. Some are good and some are bad; the same as original horror movies.

Unfortunately, Elm Street 2010 is one of those bad remakes. Though Platinum Dunes had previously hit home runs with their Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Friday the 13th reboots, they dropped the ball in a big way when it came time to give Freddy Krueger a modern day makeover, to the point that it’s hard to use any word other than ‘disastrous’ to describe their Elm Street effort.

So why then am I making a post about things I like about a movie I hate? Well, I recently found myself reading one of those self help blog articles that one of my friends linked to on Facebook, and it mentioned finding the good in all aspects of life – even the things you absolutely hate, or that make you completely miserable.

The first thing that came to mind was the Nightmare on Elm Street remake.

So in an effort to get myself on a better path in life, and overcome some of my hatred and negativity, here are five things that I actually didn’t totally hate about the film!

Springwood Diner


For such a piss poor effort, the Elm Street remake admittedly opens up on a pretty solid note. After a suitably creepy opening credits sequence, which evokes the feeling of the original movies, we’re treated to a 10 minute scene that effectively introduces all the characters, deals out a surprising death scene and even takes place in a setting that’s familiar to fans of the franchise; the Springwood diner.

In 2009 Platinum Dunes kicked off their Friday the 13th remake in a similar fashion, with a pre-title scene that managed to kinda sorta be better than anything else that came after it. Unfortunately, though Friday the 13th was still a good movie for the rest of its run-time, Elm Street totally peaks in those opening moments.

Freddy Krueger


Jackie Earle Haley is a terrific actor, and I was so excited when I heard he had been cast in the role of Freddy Krueger. Just a few years prior, he was nominated for an Oscar for playing a creepy child molester in Little Children, a role that he totally nailed. If anyone could give Robert Englund a run for his money it’d be Haley, I figured.

While Haley was perfectly cast in the role of a pre-burn Fred Krueger, it unfortunately turned out that he wasn’t exactly the right choice for a post-burn Freddy Krueger. Again, Haley is a great actor, and I don’t blame the failure of the movie on him, in any way, but he just wasn’t the right guy for the job. I almost wish that he had only played Fred Krueger, and they brought in another actor for the Freddy portions of the film. It takes a special kind of person to pull off both, the way that Englund was impressively able to do.

Don’t even get me started on the terrible makeup, which was again not Haley’s fault.

Freddy Krueger Burning


Though I wish they had delved way more into the backstory of Freddy, and really given Haley a chance to shine, I thought the flashback scene of the Springwood parents getting their revenge on Freddy was incredibly well done. In fact, I’d have to say that it’s the most visually pleasing depiction of his revenge-fueled murder that we’ve yet seen.

That shot where Freddy, surrounded by flames, peels off his coat to reveal the iconic red and green striped sweater was absolutely awesome, and was perhaps the only moment in the movie where I smiled ear to ear and got fanboy goosebumps.

Jackie Earle Haley


The most creative thing the movie did was cast a shadow of doubt over Freddy’s past, suggesting that perhaps he never molested the Springwood children, and had been wrongly murdered for crimes he didn’t commit. This idea is just about the only thing original and different that was brought to the table for the movie, which is otherwise full of lifeless recreations of moments from the original film.

Unfortunately, the ball was even dropped in this department. The question of whether or not Freddy is innocent lasts only about 15 minutes, before the idea is totally shot down, and it’s confirmed that he did indeed molest the kids. Would’ve really brought some new layers of mythos to the table if we found out he was actually innocent, and I for one would’ve loved to have seen them take the story in a new direction like that.

At the very least, they should’ve kept us, as an audience, pondering those questions for longer than a mere 15 minutes.

Micro Naps


The other mildly interesting thing they brought to the table was the idea of ‘micro-naps,’ which is a real phenomenon (thanks, Wikipedia). In the movie, they explain that if you stay awake for long periods of time, you will experience these involuntary flashes of naps, which allows for the characters to slip in and out of Freddy’s dream world, at the drop of a fedora.

It’s a cool idea, but they only really play with it in one scene (in the pharmacy), and it’s a pretty effective one. I only wish that they had more fun with the idea, rather than confining it to one scene.

Ultimately, despite these five things, it was a total lack of creativity and a string of bad choices that resulted in the failure of the movie. They really had the chance to expand the Elm Street universe, and bring something fresh, exciting and new to the table, but they instead opted for a dull and quite frankly boring rehashing of things we had already seen in the past.

It has its moments, which are all too brief, but the movie just plain blows chunks, no matter how you slice it.

I can only hope that someone comes along and tries to reboot the franchise again, because Freddy damn sure deserves another chance.

Support Halloween Love

If an item was discussed in this article that you intend on buying or renting, you can help support Halloween Love and its writers by purchasing through our links:

(Not seeing any relevant products? Start your search on Amazon through us.)
The following two tabs change content below.
If you don't get enough of me here on Halloween Love, you can also find me on Dread Central, iHorror and Shock Till You Drop. Contact me via john@halloweenlove.com.
  • Jacki Krumnow

    Wow I never thought about examining what the film did WELL, because I was always so damn disappointed in the whole of the movie. I think you did a great job at dissecting what they actually did do a decent job with. I’m just jealous I didn’t think about doing the same for my blog. Bravo man!

  • Andrea Wittenhagen

    I thought I was watching a twilight with all the Emo kids.

  • Judson

    Don’t get me started on the remake. What bugged me most was the attitude that Platinum Dunes had promoting it. There was a lot of talk about how this Freddy was going to be darker and less funny than 80’s Freddy but in the end I found him just as quippy. There was one joke he cracked about petting the dog that I thought was a bigger groaner than anything in “Dream Child”. I thought “Freddy vs Jason” did a good job of returning Freddy to his nasty roots without messing with the back story. The only good thing I’ve found that came from the remake is the fanedit “Dream Maniac”. I haven’t seen the finished version but I followed it’s progress on the FanEdit message boards for awhile. The goal was to make the remake look like a sleazy vhs rental of a cheap eighties slasher. They even use the Freddy’s Nightmares theme song in the edit which gets bonus points. It looks awesome. The actual remake was not.

  • John Squires

    Gotta find the good in bad things, sometimes. Thanks for reading, Jacki! =)

  • Charlotte Helen Nadia Cooper

    Ahh the original is still the best! Find out who Heather Langenkamp described as “Nicer and more wonderful than so many men that you would ever meet, I mean he just had a sincerity and honesty about him that was and still is, I think, very rare.”

    Read more at http://retroladyland.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/dont-go-to-sleep-retro-ladyland-has.html