Halloween Love
Horror on Amazon

Want to write for HL? Read here first. | Listen While You Read?

Why the Horror Genre Needs More Filmmakers Like Kevin Smith

Tusk walrus

On the night of September 18th, 2014, I watched veteran actor Michael Parks (at his scenery-chewing best) turn Justin Long, quite literally, into a human walrus. As Long, housed inside of a rubbery creature suit that will forever be etched into my brain, waddled across the screen, I honestly couldn’t believe my eyes. Going into my local theater on that night, I knew what the concept of the movie was, but I certainly didn’t expect Kevin Smith to actually go that far with it. It was absurd. It was over the top. But most importantly of all, it was refreshing to see a filmmaker so unhinged.

Watching Tusk, it was incredibly clear to me that while making it, Kevin Smith did not care about entertaining anyone other than Kevin Smith. That was, I can only imagine, the same mindset Smith had when making his debut feature Clerks, but Tusk was something different. It wasn’t the work of an artist finding his voice, but rather reclaiming it. It was the work of a successful Hollywood filmmaker embracing his independent spirit in the most delightfully bonkers way possible, delving so far into the extreme and absurd so as to almost ensure that he would never again be hired by a major studio.

And as crazy as it might have been, that bravery made Tusk kind of, well, beautiful.

As I sit here typing this post, Kevin Smith is at the Sundance Film Festival showing off Yoga Hosers, the second piece in his “True North Trilogy” that began back in 2014 with the aforementioned movie about a human walrus. Last night, while presenting his latest film, Smith said something that ruffled a lot of feathers in the internet film community.

As relayed on Twitter by Slash Film’s Ethan Anderton

If you’ve seen Tusk, and after you see Yoga Hosers,” Smith told the festival audience, “you’ll see that I don’t give a shit about the audience anymore.

And there it is. In his own words, an artist declaring – in case you didn’t get the boldfaced memo he called Tusk – that he’s become wise enough to not really care what anyone thinks about his art. And in a world where so many independent talents have been gobbled up by Hollywood and hired to bring its visions to life – something Smith dealt with while making Cop Out, the only directorial credit on his resume that he didn’t write – there’s something wonderful about Smith’s lack of interest in mass appeal and box office numbers: two things no artist should ever be forced to pay attention to.

Smith’s Sundance comments make it crystal clear that he has discovered a newfound selfishness within himself, and though it may make for an evocative headline to twist his words into a suggestion that he no longer cares about his fans (an absurd interpretation, for anyone who knows the first thing about him), the reality is that being selfish should, by all means, go hand-in-hand with being an artist. The problem in Hollywood is that filmmakers aren’t being given the freedom to be selfish, and by trying too hard to appeal to the ticket-buying masses, they’re creating safe, generic, and boring art.

All Smith is saying is that he has opted out of that machine, and will be dedicating the rest of his career, much the same way he started it, to staying true to himself – and, by proxy, to his like-minded, probably stoned fans. He is, in many ways, the embodiment of the indie spirit, and his career trajectory should be considered an inspiration to all filmmakers – nay, all artists. Smith got to the top of the mountain, but rather than sitting comfortably up there, he instead decided to climb back down and make his weird little movies with his friends and family members. A true independent, all these years later.

Kevin Smith is of course not the only artist who refuses to play by Hollywood’s cookie cutter rules, as Rob Zombie similarly attends Sundance this year with his partially crowd-funded horror film 31, made outside of the system. Much like Yoga Hosers, it’s a movie made for the filmmaker and his fans, rather than the movie critics who are being forced to watch and review it for their respective outlets, so don’t expect to see a lot of praise for either coming out of Sundance. And don’t expect Zombie or Smith to care.

You may hate Tusk. You may hate Lords of Salem. And you may hate Yoga Hosers and 31, when they come out later this year. You may even hate Kevin Smith and/or Rob Zombie on some sort of weird personal level, as if they wronged you in a past life – trust me, you wouldn’t be the only one. But whether you love their art, hate their art, or refuse to even acknowledge their art as actual art, nothing can change the fact that they’re making THEIR ART. And I choose to respect that.

So thank you for not giving a shit about us anymore, Kevin Smith. And please keep being you.

Support Halloween Love

If an item was discussed in this article that you intend on buying or renting, you can help support Halloween Love and its writers by purchasing through our links:

(Not seeing any relevant products? Start your search on Amazon through us.)
The following two tabs change content below.
If you don't get enough of me here on Halloween Love, you can also find me on Dread Central, iHorror and Shock Till You Drop. Contact me via JohnSquires@HalloweenLove.com
  • @SBofSelfAbuse

    Well said.

  • barry m

    The way I’ve viewed Kevin Smith from the very get go was that — no, indeed, he never really cared about the audience. I want to clarify that by audience, I mean the people seeing the movies, and NOT his fans. I was an avid independent film fan before they had the label for the films (we used to call them Art House films!), and I was eager to see Clerks, whenever it would make it’s way to our small art theater. Well… before that could happen, I’d read a few articles and interviews about Smith, and they turned me off. In these articles he’d said that he saw films by Hal Hartley and Jim Jarmusch and others of that group, and decided that ( and I paraphrase) those movies were all just people talking, and hey, I can do that! And so he did. I decided not to waste my time on Clerks, and had since read numerous articles where Smith voiced his opinions on filmmaking, and how he just didn’t care. I definitely understood his distaste for the corporate film world, and the Hollywood machine, because I hated that shit, too. I can count on my hands the number of blockbuster Hollywood films I’ve seen in the past twenty years. I prefer the small indie films. But, I believe, unlike Smith does, that small indie films are more, much more, than just people talking. They’re full of great stories, rich characters, and the best performances you’ll see anywhere. So, Kevin Smith’s version of — hey, anyone can do it — I never mustered up enough interest to see his movies.

    Until now… even though he’s still heralding that “I don’t care” line, maybe the absurdity of horror is where he can hit it. I just may see my first Kevin Smith movie. Will wonders never cease.

  • David Watson

    Love this, Mr. Squires. On point. You make the art that you want because no one else has.

  • DuckingGold

    And judging by the way Tusk failed at the box office, the audience doesn’t give a shit about Smith either. Good for them, for not supporting pretentious, self centered “artistes”.

  • Dustin Wayde MIlls

    This this this! Forever this! Thank you, John! Somebody needed to acknowledge it, and you did so very eloquently.

  • Sebastian Villegas

    To be honest, I disagree. No. I’d argue Smith is doing more harm than good for Horror. Something like Tusk despite some good dialogue heavy scenes, it’s not very good. So many things were total misfires like the tone, Depp’s character, Justin Long’s character is not an entertaining asshole in the slightest. Now, Kevin Smith wants to make the films he wants to make. Fine, let him do that. I won’t start a petition. But that being said, we don’t need more Kevin Smiths for the Horror. We don’t. What need is more filmmakers like Jennifer Kent or David Robert Mitchell. They GET Horror. Hell, more Soska sisters than Kevin Smith. Hell, you know which Horror film from Sundance I hear is WAY BETTER than Yoga Hosers? Babak Anvari’s Under The Shadow. That is more promising. I want more exposure for that film than any of Smith’s works. It’s a crime that I saw Tusk in theaters and not a film like The Guest.

    Plus, I like artists who make films because they want to. Kevin Smith just isn’t a very good one. ;)