Comments on: Rolling Stone Ranks the Best & Worst Horror Remakes. My Thoughts. https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/Halloween & Horror BlogFri, 20 Jul 2018 05:05:54 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0.2 By: Attack of the Couch https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7370Sat, 06 Jun 2015 11:47:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7370I agree with most of your opinions, although I like Zombie’s Halloween quite a bit more. The Black Christmas remake is a blast. I like my slashers campy, violent and incestuous; in those regards it delivers in bucket loads.

]]>
By: John Kuehne https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7365Wed, 03 Jun 2015 17:56:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7365I gotta disagree with the TCM remake – they made leather face a badass instead of the mentally-handicapped inbred idiot he is supposed to be. I found the TCM remake as painful as you found the NOES remake.

]]>
By: Humanary Stew https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7364Wed, 03 Jun 2015 10:28:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7364The last time Rolling Stone wrote anything of relevance was…never.

]]>
By: John Squires https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7363Wed, 03 Jun 2015 05:05:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7363In reply to Stevie Lee Rothferd.

Thanks for reading and commenting, Stevie. I love Rob Zombie, I just wish he had spent his time making two more of his own movies, rather than Halloween & Halloween 2. He’s too good to be remaking someone else’s work. Halloween wasn’t a complete fail, but it just didn’t really work for me.

As for Black Christmas, I think a big part of being a horror fan is being able to recognize that a movie isn’t very good, but still loving it. Truth be told, a lot of my favorite horror movies – like Ice Cream Man – are pretty damn bad!

]]>
By: John Squires https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7362Wed, 03 Jun 2015 05:03:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7362In reply to Stevie Lee Rothferd.

Trolls will be trolls. I’ve learned to just make peace with comments like that and let them roll off my back.

]]>
By: Stevie Lee Rothferd https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7361Wed, 03 Jun 2015 04:53:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7361I don’t think it was terrible…watching that many well done practical effects is at least fun…but I agree with your basic point.

ANOES…now that was truly terrible. And not fun. But I do enjoy some of the mood and setting, even so.

]]>
By: Stevie Lee Rothferd https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7360Wed, 03 Jun 2015 04:51:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7360I wish that Halloween was the masterpiece it could have been, but for me, its the opposite that makes it fall short. He had a super interesting premise, with a nice creepy, moody build-up (and some crappy dialogue, no denying) and a bumch of sweet imagery for the first 45 minutes or so…then basically crams Carpenter’s reworked film into about 50 minutes at the end. Its a shame the studio didn’t let him break the first film up into two, where he becomes ‘The Shape’ at the end of the first. That could have been truly unique and interesting…and it would have saved us from the atrocious H2 in the process.

Also, I like what you said about Black Christmas here. It’s not noted often enough nowadays that bad horror movies can still be fun. We knew that growing up, but it seems like we’ve gotten to a point of cynical disdain for anything that doesn’t land right where it should.

Great piece, John.

]]>
By: Stevie Lee Rothferd https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7359Wed, 03 Jun 2015 04:44:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7359In reply to Kelly Wilkins.

I hate dumb ass commments like this. Even if if what you commented was a real point, it doesn’t render the whole article pointless. The internet has made people lazy communicators.

]]>
By: John Squires https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7357Tue, 02 Jun 2015 23:43:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7357In reply to Kelly Wilkins.

Haha. Fair enough. It’s not that I “can’t tell” it’s a prequel. Yes, it is technically a prequel, in that it centers on the events PRIOR to Carpenter’s movie. But really, it was just a clever (and smart) way to remake The Thing, without actually remaking it. And I don’t fault the film for that, but let’s call a spade a spade.

]]>
By: Kelly Wilkins https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7356Tue, 02 Jun 2015 23:34:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7356the fact that you can’t tell that The Thing was a prequel automatically makes your article moot.

]]>
By: Luke Sutphin https://halloweenlove.com/rolling-stone-ranks-the-best-worst-horror-remakes-my-thoughts/#comment-7355Tue, 02 Jun 2015 23:25:00 +0000https://halloweenlove.com/?p=15374#comment-7355Love the Halloween remake but thought the friday the 13th was terrible. Also love black xmas but yet to see original. Overall though a pretty good list

]]>