There’s always a fine line between the art, the artists, and the fans. Of course, art (at least most art), is meant to be seen by as many people as possible. Naturally, when you throw business into the mix (which is a necessary evil — projects are often only possible because they’re backed by money), things tend to get a bit messy.

The legal department’s default stance of just about any company involved in producing art is to never officially give permission for fan art, fan fiction, and other “unauthorized” projects, even where and when they might actually appreciate it (fandom is free publicity).

Some companies are cool and treat fans very well, some “go after” anyone they feel encroaches on their trademarks or copyrights whether it’s fair use or involving commercializing indiscriminately, and everything in-between. Sometimes it’s appropriate. Most of the time, it’s overreaching.

NDAs are ubiquitous in business and often used inappropriately. However, in this case, at least back in 2005, I think the NDAs were fair, even morally. I mean it’s standard practice for actors of big, upcoming movies to have to sign NDAs and it makes total sense. The filmmakers don’t want them spoiling anything both for ethical and economic reasons.

That appears to be the main point of this NDA. They wanted to keep the show under wraps until actually released. That’s fair. Obviously, as we know, the show never actually released and will never see the light of day, so it’s all a bit moot now. After a decade, I see no problem with people now sharing their experiences. If you’re in contact with any other contestants that are afraid to share, but want to, they can absolutely share anonymously and I’ll share whatever they’ve got on their behalf. :)