Halloween Love
Horror on Amazon

Want to write for HL? Read here first. | Listen While You Read?

Black Sheep of the Franchise: 5 WTF Sequels

Black Sheep of the Franchise Banner

Let’s face it, our favorite horror franchises love to repeat themselves. Take a look at Friday the 13th for instance: Nubile teens in the woods? Check. Copious amounts of sex and drugs? Check. A vengeful paramedic killing them off one by….wait, what?! That’s right, every now and then the filmmakers behinds these series decide it’s time to try something new. Of course, us fans embrace them no matter…wait, no?

Okay, so usually fans don’t appreciate Hollywood producers trying to mess with their franchise recipes. That’s how we end up with the “Black Sheep” of the franchise, the one film that just wanted to be different – that thought maybe it was too cool to play with all the others. I’ve decided to round up 5 different “Black Sheep”, those franchise entries that just stand out from the rest. Here we go!

Friday the 13th: A New Beginning

F13 A New Beginning

When it comes to Friday the 13th there were several options for picking a Black Sheep. On the one hand we have a demon slug monster and a cyborg makeover in space, but I decided to keep my choice pre-New Line cinema (we may revisit those other entries somewhere down the line).

Why is it a Black Sheep: It’s a Jason film without Jason! After one kid goes psycho in the halfway house and chops up the annoying dude munching on a chocolate bar, the bodies start dropping like – well, like they normally do in Crystal Lake. Only this time, it turns out the killer is dead chocolate bar guy’s pissed off farther. He’s donned a hockey mask (with blue stripes instead of Jason’s typical red) to copycat himself through a murder spree. I personally enjoy this entry, but upon it’s release and after “the big reveal”, fans were not happy. Paramount rushed to get Friday the 13th Part 6: Jason Lives into theaters the following year…with Jason , of course, back in action.

Phantasm IV: Oblivion

Phantasm: Oblivion

Everyone is in a Phantasm frenzy with the release of the fifth and final film this week, but even this beloved franchise has its own Black Sheep. Since the films aren’t the most straight forward narratively, they could typically get away with almost anything, but Oblivion is the one that most fans generally write off.

Why is it a Black Sheep: After heading to the DTV graveyard with the third film, Don Coscarelli decided to go back to the original’s roots by making an extremely low budget, scaled back sequel. That’s all well and good, but the use of of deleted scenes from the first film and over use of the series’ inter-dimensional time shifts left even the most extreme phans scratching their heads. What did it all mean? Why was there a Sentinel in Mike’s head? How is Mike still alive after having said Sentinel ripped from said head? Did Coscarelli even know when he was making this film? (I still like it, though)

Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Dead

NOES 2 Freddy's Revenge

Wes Craven’s original film was a true game changer. It practically put New Line Cinemas on the map, hence the name “The House that Freddy Built”. So, it’s no surprise they wanted a sequel to the smash hit right away, only Craven was busy working on other projects. They moved ahead without him, and this is what we got.

Why is it a Black Sheep: Freddy’s Revenge is a super fun (and really homoerotic) movie, but it’s clear that New Line had no idea what they had in the character of Freddy just yet. They don’t follow any of the previous film’s rules: Freddy can now possess people, be defeated by love, and attack people when they’re awake. New Line even tried to recast Robert Englund with a stunt guy in a mask! Needless to say, after one day of shooting with “faux Freddy” they had Englund back on set pronto! It wasn’t until the next film, Dream Warriors (arguably the best sequel in the franchise), brought Craven back to write and produce that audiences were given the Freddy they had originally loved to fear, and the series was back on track.

Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation

TCM Next Generation

The original Texas Chainsaw Massacre’s screenwriter, Kim Henkel, returns to the series 30 years later to bring us The Next Generation. The film starred young, upcoming stars Renee Zellwegger and Matthew McConaughey. Sounds great, right?!

Why is it a Black Sheep: This film is almost unanimously panned by fans and critics alike. I’ve considered giving it a re-watch recently, especially after reading John Squire’s analysis of the film here and interview with Henkel here, but ultimately the film goes way too far off the rails. Leatherface goes full on drag (pictured above) and the plot somehow involves the Illuminati?! This one was practically buried by fans after its release.

Halloween 3: Season of the Witch

Halloween 3 - Laser

John Carpenter was no longer interested in continuing the adventure of Michael Myers and Laurie Strode, but producers wanted to make some more money. What’s a guy to do? Well, Carpenter decided to turn the Halloween series into an anthology. Each film would tell an entirely new story centered around the holiday. Cool.

Why is it a Black Sheep: The only problem with that is audiences were expecting The Shape back in action with a big ol’ butcher knife. What they got instead was the story of an evil mask maker intent on destroying the nation’s children for blood sacrifice by having them tune into a commercial on Halloween night that would activate a chip in their masks made with pieces of Stonehenge, thus melting their heads into puddles of snakes and bugs. Don’t forget to breathe after that synopsis. Oh, and there’s some robots and shit too. This film is insane and was a total bomb at the box office. After it went bust, only a few years later, producers brought us Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers. Return he did, and so did the box office cash.

To be completely honest, I love Halloween 3! It’s crazy, and just so much fun. It’s the perfect film to capture the Halloween season. Just watch this clip below and tell me if you don’t agree.

If you’re still there and haven’t disintegrated into a festering pile of insects, tell me, what’re some of your favorite Black Sheep of the Franchise?

Support Halloween Love

If an item was discussed in this article that you intend on buying or renting, you can help support Halloween Love and its writers by purchasing through our links:

(Not seeing any relevant products? Start your search on Amazon through us.)
The following two tabs change content below.

Zachary Paul

I'm a long time horror nerd and wannabe director. My inspirations are varied from Wes Craven, Dario Argento, George Romero, Lucio Fulci, John Carpenter, and even some John Waters and Joss Whedon. My tastes are all over the place within the genre. Give me highbrow, gross out, slow burn, rubber suit wearing, action/horror hybrid...I love it all. I enjoy writing and talking about all aspects of horror. BONUS FACT: I love cooking and eating anything with pumpkin in it. Find me on Twitter @BringBackMM :)
  • J Jett

    Hi Zach! great article! i have to admit i very much like like F13 pt.5. it’s the last F13 film to have any good atmosphere/creepiness and some of the kills were freaking brutal (the leather strap around the eyes/the gardening shears to the eyes).

  • Creepshow

    Halloween III is my favorite based solely on the fact that there is no Michael Myers. Of all slasher films, I find the Halloweens to be the most boring and difficult to sit through.

  • Yeah, it was some brutal/sleazy stuff. Apparently the director had a background in porn which could possibly explain the grimy atmosphere of the whole thing.

  • Always the contrarian. :) Halloween is actually one of my favorite slasher franchises, but I really do love them all. I appreciate that the Halloween films were so simple…until they weren’t anyway.

  • Creepshow

    It cracks me up how Tom Atkins beds two complete strangers, in Season of the Witch, and The Fog. Although we didn’t see him get busy with Jaime Lee Curtis in the Fog, he either just finished or was about to. And in Halloween III, he was old enough to be her father. Ew…XD.

  • Yes. While I personally can’t say for sure if I would turn down 80’s era Tom Atkins (he has his own special brand of swagger), he’s certainly not a conventionally good looking dude. But in Season of the Witch they really STRESS just what a ladie’s man he is, an alcoholic, dead beat dad, ladie’s man.

  • Creepshow

    Haha! He brings his kids crappy masks, in a brown lunch bag.

  • “Yeah, dad, we want the ones that’ll turn our heads into a mush of critters!”

  • Matt

    Nice list. Though they certainly are Black Sheep, I like all of the films listed, save for one – Friday the 13th: A New Beginning. While I agree with J that it had some great kills, I felt completely robbed by the reveal. Man, was I pissed! The only reason I keep it in my collection is because I’m a completest. (That’s the same reason I have three versions of Rob Zombie’s Halloween and two versions of H2.)

    One of my most favorite Black Sheep films is one you briefly touched on in the beginning of this article – Jason X. This film is considered to be at of near the bottom of the barrel by most Friday fans. I’m not ashamed to say that I really loved that movie. It’s actually one of my favorites in the series.

    Though the “In Space” thing had already been done by Leprechaun and Hellraiser, it was something “different” in the Friday universe (see what I did there?). It was pure camp, covered with cheese, and came with a side order of silliness, but it was such a fun film IMO. One of the most reviled aspects of the film, the Android, was actually one of my favorite parts. Lisa Ryder as Kay-Em was great. She was bold, bad-ass, and completely fearless. A perfect foil for Jason, who instilled fear in all who crossed his path.

  • Being a completest is a curse us horror fan will always bare.